- 90'+7' Juan Torres (Charleston Battery) Yellow Card at 97'
- 89' Leland Archer (Charleston Battery) Substitution at 89'
- 88' Greg Hurst (New Mexico United) Yellow Card at 88'
- 76' Greg Hurst (New Mexico United) Substitution at 76'
- 76' McKinze Gaines (New Mexico United) Substitution at 76'
- 76' Tomas Pondeca (New Mexico United) Substitution at 76'
- 73' Chris Allan (Charleston Battery) Substitution at 73'
- 68' Rubio Rubín (Charleston Battery) Goal at 68'
- 64' Chris Gloster (New Mexico United) Substitution at 64'
- 64' Sergio Rivas (New Mexico United) Substitution at 64'
- 63' Jon-Talen Maples (New Mexico United) Penalty - Scored at 63'
- 60' Arturo Rodriguez (Charleston Battery) Substitution at 60'
- 60' Cal Jennings (Charleston Battery) Substitution at 60'
- 60' Rubio Rubín (Charleston Battery) Substitution at 60'
- 49' Ousman Jabang (New Mexico United) Own Goal at 49'
- 38' Ousman Jabang (New Mexico United) Yellow Card at 38'
- 32' Houssou Landry (Charleston Battery) Yellow Card at 32'
- 30' Marlon Vargas (New Mexico United) Yellow Card at 30'
